What Pastors Who Keep Growing as Leaders Do Differently from Pastors Who Plateau

Two pastors begin ministry with the same gifts, same training, the same passion for the calling. Ten years later, one is more wise and capable than they were on day one. The other is doing the same thing, just with more polish and practice.

The difference rarely has to do with innate gifts. Pastors who continue to grow as leaders do a small number of things differently than pastors who plateau, and it’s all done intentionally and consistently.

They view learning as a discipline and not as an event.

Pastors who plateau tend to treat learning and growth as something that happens at a conference. Pastors who continue growing integrate learning and growth into their weekly rhythms in the same way they do prayer and sermon prep. They read books outside of their wheelhouse, ask questions in rooms in which they’re not the authority, and treat every season of ministry (even the boring and difficult ones) as a classroom.

Notice how Jesus described discipleship, not as an event but as a daily posture: “Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross daily and follow me” (Luke 9:23). And growth as a leader is the same. It’s a discipline, not an event.

They Lead Themselves Before They Try to Lead Anyone Else

A pastor who fails to learn to lead oneself will find himself incapable of leading anyone else for a long time to come. Pastoral leaders who keep on growing see self-leadership as the basis on which the rest of their leadership is built.

It manifests itself in small but significant ways: keeping a weekly Sabbath instead of doing whatever you want, speaking truthfully to a counselor or mentor about your struggles, and making decisions about time and energy based on the ministry of Jesus rather than the opinion of others. A pastor who can’t lead herself will eventually run out of leadership to give others.

Paul told Timothy to watch his life and doctrine closely, because doing so would save both himself and those who heard him (1 Timothy 4:16). And notice that self-leadership is not about you; it’s about making sure you are the sort of person who can faithfully minister to others over a long career.

They Build Peer Community Instead of Staying Isolated

Pastoral leaders who plateau do so because they are in isolation either because the vocation lends itself to that, or because the higher you rise, the more people expect you to have your act together. Pastors who keep growing build community with peers, other leaders who understand the burdens of the pastorate and can speak truth into their lives.

Iron sharpens iron, and one person sharpens another (Proverbs 27:17). Sharpening is what happens when a peer pushes you to get better. Sharpening takes friction and a certain level of discomfort. You don’t sharpen someone if you like their posture and poise. You sharpen someone if they’re not where they need to be in a certain area. A pastor without a sharpener will always find himself in the same place.

They Multiply Rather Than Accumulate

There’s a subtle temptation in ministry for a leader’s growth to become an inward spiral. Pastors who keep growing reject that temptation. They don’t just ask “how do I get better,” instead they ask “who do I develop to get better?”

A leader who develops other leaders creates a multiplying rather than an accumulating effect. A pastor who invests in an associate, a young leader on staff, or a volunteer with promise is not only generous, but they are extending their reach and building their capability far beyond what they could on their own. Every hour you invest in developing someone else compounds in ways personal study alone never can.

They Choose Structured Community Over Sporadic Inspiration

The final way that pastors who keep growing are different from pastors who plateau is that rather than rely on willpower alone, they create structure. Structure helps you grow because inspiration is fickle.

This is why EQUIP exists. Our programs Beyond Success, Bridge Builder, EQUIP Events, and Vision Trips provide pastors and church leaders with community for continuous, impactful development. We are part of a global network of more than 170 countries, providing opportunities for connection and growth that last far beyond the end of the program.

Plateau is not a product of a pastor’s gifts or calling. It’s almost always a lack of structure. If you feel like your growth as a leader has taken a nosedive lately, you’re probably right. And the solution is the right community and the right program to keep you learning inside of it.

Tim Elmore
Tim ElmoreFounder & CEO, Growing Leaders
Tim Elmore is a bestselling author and international speaker who equips educators, coaches, and parents to develop leadership in the next generation. He has authored more than 35 books and spoken to over 500,000 students, educators, and professionals.

In This Article

Share This Post
LinkedIn
X / Twitter

Ideas That Start Ripples, Delivered Weekly.

Join educators, coaches, and parents leading the next generation.

More From The Blog

Why the Best Discipleship Programs Are Also Leadership Development Programs

Discipleship without leadership development stalls at the exit door. Discover why the best discipleship leadership training curriculum multiplies leaders. [...]

Why Values-Based Leadership Is the Most Sustainable Competitive Advantage for Small Business Owners

Discover why values-based leadership training for business owners builds the trust that sustains companies long after quarterly numbers fade. [...]

Why Pastoral Leadership Development Is the Most Neglected Priority in Church Health

Pastors develop everyone in the church but themselves. Here's why pastoral leadership development can't stay optional, and where to start. [...]